9th March 2016
Here are five things to remember when you hear the Prime Minister praise the “sovereignty of parliament”.
First, ministers and officials are encouraged to use statutory instruments as much as possible, which do not get proper parliamentary scrutiny.
Second, the government has sought to cut the “Short money” which funds the scrutiny work of opposition parties in parliament.
Third, the government is seeking to push through the Investigatory Powers Bill through parliament at speed, just as it did with the Data Retention and Investigatory Powers Act.
Fourth, when the House of Lords (sensibly) rejected cuts to certain benefits (which were later dropped), Cameron sought to limit the power of the Lords.
Fifth, when the Speaker of the House of Commons was seen as too independent, the (then Coalition) government under Cameron attempted (and failed) to get the Speaker sacked.
Take together the increasing use of secondary legislation, the attempts to cut Short money, the rushing of primary legislation, the attempt to limit the Lords, and the plans to eject the Speaker – and the evidence does not show that Cameron and his government have any sincere respect for the sovereignty of parliament.
In fact, the evidence contradicts the notion that Cameron and his government believe in the rights and prerogatives of the legislature.
And this is without the ongoing tendency for major announcements to be leaked to the press, or to be revealed on chat shows, rather than on the floor of the Commons.
In essence, it is not the sovereignty of parliament which is being claimed by Cameron and his ministers, but the sovereignty of the government once it has a Commons majority; what a former Conservative Lord Chancellor called an “elective dictatorship“.
The rhetoric may be about the sovereighty of parliament, but the practice of the current government (as with previous governments) is to undermine parliament in as many ways as possible.
It is not Brussels which is the greatest enemy of the Westminster parliament but Whitehall.
Regular blogging at Jack of Kent is made possible by the kind sponsorship of Hammicks Legal Information Services.
If you value this this blog and its free content, please do two things.
First, click on this link to Hammicks and have a browse.
Second, please subscribe for alerts for my new posts at Jack of Kent and the FT, and anywhere else. Just submit your email address in the “Subscribe” box on this page. Twitter and other social media platforms may not always be around – and so by subscribing you will get alerts for my posts.