26th April 2016
Human Rights and ECHR
Theresa May, the Home Secretary, gave a speech yesterday which included a call for the United Kingdom to leave the European Convention on Human Rights.
The statement is, of course, more about the politics of Brexit and succession to the Tory leadership than anything serious about law and policy. It is a sort of counter-balance to her position on the UK remaining in the European Union.
For a number of reasons, not least that the Good Friday agreement requires the ECHR to have continual legal effect in Northern Ireland, this demand will go nowhere.
(I set out the seven hurdles for repeal of the Human Rights Act and for UK leaving the ECHR – including the problems presented by Northern Ireland and Scottish devolution – in a post here last May.)
Given the office Theresa May holds, it is worth taking a moment to look at the Northern Ireland point, for the UK to leave the ECHR would require the UK to reopen and renegotiate the Good Friday agreement.
This is the provision of the Good Friday agreement of which UK will be in breach if Theresa May got her way on ECHR. pic.twitter.com/1NnI3dM9sT
— David Allen Green (@DavidAllenGreen) April 25, 2016
Any change to the agreement would, in turn, require fresh referendums in Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.
It would also risk alienating the nationalists who accepted the Police Service of Northern Ireland only as long as it was subject to the ECHR.
It is, in all, a remarkable demand for a serving Home Secretary to make, and it is also extraordinary for the Home Office to post the statement on their own site as if it is government policy – and here it should be noted that policy on the Human Rights Act is (supposedly) under the Ministry of Justice, and not the Home Office.
This does not seem thought through. One suspects the Home Secretary does not realise (or does not care) about the implications of the UK leaving the ECHR – perhaps her desire to send a political signal to Tory back-benchers and the popular media is too great.
Regular blogging at Jack of Kent is made possible by the kind sponsorship of Hammicks Legal Information Services. Please click on this link to Hammicks and have a browse.
Please subscribe for alerts for my new posts at Jack of Kent and the FT, and anywhere else. Just submit your email address in the “Subscribe” box on this page.
Twitter and other social media platforms may not always be around – and so by subscribing you will get alerts for my posts…